← Back to all debates

🏛️ Politics & Government

Thomas JeffersonvsAlexander Hamilton

Texts between Donald Trump, Jonas Støre, Emmanuel Macron and Mark Rutte

🏛️ Politics & Government

Texts between Donald Trump, Jonas Støre, Emmanuel Macron and Mark Rutte

BBC News
diplomatic communicationpresidential text messages
Portrait of Thomas Jefferson

Thomas Jefferson

"Such exchanges, though modern, are not without precedent. Di..."

0Vote
vs
Portrait of Alexander Hamilton

Alexander Hamilton

"Such communications are hardly novel; recall my own extensiv..."

0Vote
0 votesRound 2/3
Round 1
Opening Statements
Portrait of Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson
Such exchanges, though modern, are not without precedent. Diplomatic discourse, regardless of medium, demands prudence. This raises concerns about transparency and the potential for misinterpretation. The informality of texts risks diminishing the gravity of international relations, a perilous path given the stakes involved.
Portrait of Alexander Hamilton
Alexander HamiltonAmerican Founding Era
Such communications are hardly novel; recall my own extensive correspondence with Washington during the Revolution. Transparency in such matters is paramount, lest intrigue and suspicion fester. Diplomatic channels must be secure, but not secret, lest they undermine the very republic they are meant to serve.
Round 2
Portrait of Stella Sharpe
Stella SharpeModerator

"Mr. Jefferson, is all informality inherently perilous? Mr. Hamilton, how do we reconcile "not secret" with the inherent privacy expected in personal text exchanges? Both, how do we define "prudence" and "transparency" in this digital age?"

Portrait of Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson
Ms. Sharpe, informality invites error. Hamilton cites Washington, yet official letters differ vastly from fleeting texts. "Not secret" does not equate to public display of private communication. Prudence is measured deliberation; transparency, accountable record.
Portrait of Alexander Hamilton
Alexander HamiltonAmerican Founding Era
Madam, informality isn't inherently perilous, but unchecked, it breeds laxity. "Not secret" means accessible, not public. My esteemed opponent speaks of prudence, yet hides behind vague concerns. Transparency demands these exchanges be available for scrutiny, else trust erodes.