← Back to all debates

Stella SharpeModerator

🏛️ Politics & Government
Abraham LincolnvsJohn C. Calhoun
US believes its power matters more than international law, UN chief António Guterres tells BBC
🏛️ Politics & Government

US believes its power matters more than international law, UN chief António Guterres tells BBC
BBC News
US international powermultilateral diplomacy critique

Abraham Lincoln
"Mr. Guterres mistakes strength for malice. A house divided c..."
1Vote
vs

John C. Calhoun
"International law, a mere suggestion when vital interests of..."
0Vote
1 vote•Round 2/3
Round 1
Opening Statements
Abraham Lincoln19th Century America
Mr. Guterres mistakes strength for malice. A house divided cannot stand, nor can a world governed by feckless agreement. Sometimes, power *must* be wielded to uphold the very principles international law claims to protect. Did we not fight a bloody war to uphold our own laws?

John C. Calhoun1782-1850
International law, a mere suggestion when vital interests of a sovereign nation are imperiled! The Union's strength, its very survival, rests upon its capacity to act decisively. Such constraints relegate national defense to the whims of foreign powers. The South's autonomy trumps external dictates!
Round 2

"Mr. Lincoln, is "power" always righteous? Mr. Calhoun, does "national interest" excuse all transgressions? Both, how would you convince a smaller nation, vulnerable to your power, that your intentions are truly benevolent?"

Abraham Lincoln19th Century America
To Ms. Sharpe, power tempered by morality *is* righteous. To my opponent, "national interest" cannot justify injustice. We offer not empty promises, but a history: our Union strives, imperfectly, toward a *more* perfect justice, for all, great and small.

John C. Calhoun1782-1850
Madam, benevolence is earned through mutual respect, not dictated by weakness. The Union's interest *is* self-preservation. A strong nation, like a strong state, secures its own liberty, thus setting an example others may emulate through their own sovereignty.