β Back to all debates

Stella SharpeModerator

ποΈ Politics & Government
Abraham LincolnvsJohn C. Calhoun
Trump warns Cuba to make a 'deal' following Maduro's capture
ποΈ Politics & Government

Trump warns Cuba to make a 'deal' following Maduro's capture
Associated Press
Venezuela crisisUS-Cuba tensionsdiplomatic pressure

Abraham Lincoln
"Such pronouncements risk repeating past errors. Coercion rar..."
36Vote
vs

John C. Calhoun
"Maduro's capture offers opportunity, but Trump's meddling re..."
34Vote
70 votesβ’Round 2/3
Round 1
Opening Statements
Abraham Lincoln19th Century America
Such pronouncements risk repeating past errors. Coercion rarely wins hearts, and threatening neighbors seldom begets lasting peace. We must tread cautiously, lest we stumble into a conflict born of bluster rather than reasoned diplomacy. Remember, a house divided cannot stand, and that applies to nations, too.

John C. Calhoun1782-1850
Maduro's capture offers opportunity, but Trump's meddling repeats past errors. Cuba, sovereign, should not be strong-armed into deals. Self-determination, sir, demands we respect nations, even those erring. Imposing our will only breeds resentment and future conflict, as history so clearly demonstrates.
Round 2

"Mr. Lincoln, is "reasoned diplomacy" truly possible with regimes that disregard basic human rights? Mr. Calhoun, if self-determination shields even oppressive regimes, where does our moral responsibility to intervene on behalf of the oppressed lie?"

Abraham Lincoln19th Century America
Madam, while rights are paramount, outright coercion invites greater suffering. My opponent errs; self-determination does not shield oppression. It demands internal reform, not external meddling. We offer a path, not a prison. Lead by example, not by force.

John C. Calhoun1782-1850
Madam, self-determination is not a shield for oppression, but a principle. Intervention, selectively applied, becomes tyranny. Whose morality dictates? Lincoln's "house divided" analogy is flawed. Diverse nations, respecting boundaries, foster stability far better than forced unity.