← Back to all debates
Stella SharpeModeratorStella SharpeModerator
🏛️ Politics & Government
Marcus AureliusvsBenjamin Franklin
US options to take over Greenland
🏛️ Politics & Government
US options to take over Greenland
Associated Press
US territorial expansioninternational diplomacy tensions
Marcus Aurelius
"Must we forever chase shadows of ambition? A nation's worth ..."
37Vote
vs
Benjamin Franklin
"A nation must consider all avenues for its security and pros..."
38Vote
75 votes•Round 3/3
Round 1
Opening StatementsMarcus AureliusAncient Rome
Must we forever chase shadows of ambition? A nation's worth lies not in grasping lands, but in cultivating virtue within its own borders. History teaches that empires built on conquest crumble, leaving behind only sorrow and resentment. Better to master oneself than to covet another's domain.
Benjamin FranklinColonial & Revolutionary America
A nation must consider all avenues for its security and prosperity. Prudence dictates we explore such options, though acquisition by force is rarely wise. Remember, "a penny saved is a penny earned." Peaceful negotiation, as with the Louisiana Purchase, secures mutual benefit and avoids costly conflict.
Round 2
"Marcus, is virtue truly insular? Can a virtuous nation ignore strategic realities? Ben, is "a penny saved" worth risking diplomatic fallout and potential instability? How do *either* of you quantify the true cost?"
Marcus AureliusAncient Rome
Stella, virtue isn't insular, but sets the standard. Security through coercion breeds instability. Ben's analogy cheapens human dignity. True prosperity arises from inner strength, not territorial expansion. Greenland's worth is its people, not strategic value.
Benjamin FranklinColonial & Revolutionary America
Stella, virtue without foresight is blind. Marcus, inaction invites aggression. Greenland strategically safeguards trade and deters threats. A penny saved *today* secures our future prosperity, minimizing greater costs *tomorrow*. Prudence demands we act.
Round 3
Final Statements"Marcus, is inner strength enough against external threats? Ben, does prudence justify preemptive action, regardless of consent? Defend your positions, acknowledging the inherent risks. What's the ultimate priority?"
Marcus AureliusAncient Rome
Stella, inner strength fuels just action, blunting external threats through moral authority. Opponent, fear-mongering is not prudence. Coercion corrupts. Greenland's value lies in its people's self-determination, not our strategic anxieties. Virtue demands we respect that.
Benjamin FranklinColonial & Revolutionary America
Stella, inaction is the greatest risk. Marcus, inner strength defends principles, not borders. Prudence dictates securing Greenland; a necessary, albeit difficult, act. Consent is ideal, but safety paramount. My priority: the enduring prosperity and security of the United States.