← Back to all debates

🏛️ Politics & Government

Thomas JeffersonvsAlexander Hamilton

Denmark, Greenland envoys met with White House officials over 'takeover'

🏛️ Politics & Government

Denmark, Greenland envoys met with White House officials over 'takeover'

Associated Press
Arctic diplomacyUS-Denmark relationsterritorial tensions
Portrait of Thomas Jefferson

Thomas Jefferson

"Such an acquisition, however enticing, smacks of an overreac..."

41Vote
vs
Portrait of Alexander Hamilton

Alexander Hamilton

"A "takeover" is a gross exaggeration! Vigorous diplomacy is ..."

40Vote
81 votesRound 2/3
Round 1
Opening Statements
Portrait of Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson
Such an acquisition, however enticing, smacks of an overreach ill-befitting our republican ideals. Expansion must arise from the consent of the governed, not from shadowed meetings implying coercion. To pursue Greenland absent its people's clear will invites future discord and undermines our moral standing.
Portrait of Alexander Hamilton
Alexander HamiltonAmerican Founding Era
A "takeover" is a gross exaggeration! Vigorous diplomacy is the lifeblood of a strong nation. We must secure strategic advantages where we find them. Remember the Louisiana Purchase? Bold action yields prosperity; timid inaction, decay. Let us not shrink from asserting our interests in the Arctic.
Round 2
Portrait of Stella Sharpe
Stella SharpeModerator

"Mr. Jefferson, consent is noble, but was Louisiana's truly universal? Mr. Hamilton, "strategic advantage" at what cost? Is Greenland a prize, or a people? Both, address the indigenous perspective directly."

Portrait of Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson
Ms. Sharpe, a flawed precedent does not justify repeating error. Louisiana's acquisition, though beneficial, lacked full consent. To Hamilton, strategic advantage gained through veiled coercion is a Pyrrhic victory, staining our nation's honor and ignoring Greenland's inhabitants' inherent rights.
Portrait of Alexander Hamilton
Alexander HamiltonAmerican Founding Era
Ms. Sharpe, a fair point. Ideally, consent is universal, yet reality is rarely ideal. As for Greenland, strategic advantage *secures* prosperity for *all*, including its indigenous peoples. My opponent speaks of "coercion"; I speak of opportunity. We offer partnership, not subjugation.