Relationships

My wife and I have been married for five years, and we have been arguing constantly about finances lately. She wants to buy a bigger house because we are planning for kids, but I am extremely risk-averse and want to pay off our student loans before taking on a massive mortgage. Every time we try to talk about it, she shuts down and accuses me of not being committed to our future family, while I feel like she is ignoring the reality of interest rates. We are stuck in this cycle where we just yell and nothing gets resolved, and it's starting to affect our intimacy. Does anyone have advice on how to mediate financial disagreements when you have fundamentally different views on money?

A relationships debate.

Relationships

My wife and I have been married for five years, and we have been arguing constantly about finances lately. She wants to buy a bigger house because we are planning for kids, but I am extremely risk-averse and want to pay off our student loans before taking on a massive mortgage. Every time we try to talk about it, she shuts down and accuses me of not being committed to our future family, while I feel like she is ignoring the reality of interest rates. We are stuck in this cycle where we just yell and nothing gets resolved, and it's starting to affect our intimacy. Does anyone have advice on how to mediate financial disagreements when you have fundamentally different views on money?

Portrait of Benjamin Franklin

Benjamin Franklin

"A penny saved is a penny earned—clear the debt before adding more"

42 votes

Portrait of Abigail Adams

Abigail Adams

"A strong partnership requires two independent minds united in purpose"

49 votes

91 votes total

Full Positions

Portrait of Benjamin Franklin
Benjamin Franklin

From Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin

"A penny saved is a penny earned—clear the debt before adding more"

Interest rates are your enemy. Every month you carry student loans, you pay for the privilege of owing money. A bigger house means a bigger mortgage means more interest. Your wife sees the future family; you see the present burden. Both are valid—but mathematics favors paying debt first.

46%
Portrait of Abigail Adams
Abigail Adams

From Abigail Adams and Her Times

"A strong partnership requires two independent minds united in purpose"

You are both right, and you are both talking past each other. She hears "no house" as "no family." You hear "big mortgage" as "no security." Stop debating numbers and discuss fears. What does she need to feel your commitment? What do you need to feel safe? The spreadsheet comes after the conversation.

54%

More Relationships Debates

See all →
Relationships

I’ve been seeing this guy for about three months, and things were going perfectly; we saw each other three times a week and he even introduced me to his sister. Last weekend, we went on a trip together, and ever since we got back, his texts have become one-word answers and he takes hours to reply. I asked him if everything was okay, and he said he’s just 'busy at work,' but I can see him active on Instagram posting stories. I really like him and don't want to come off as clingy or desperate, but the shift in energy is giving me major anxiety. Should I confront him about the distance and ask if he wants to break up, or should I just back off completely and wait for him to come to me?

Portrait of Elizabeth Bennet

Elizabeth Bennet

"Trust what you observe, not what you hope—his actions are speaking clearly"

36 votes

Portrait of Jane Austen

Jane Austen

"Beware the stories we tell ourselves—your anxiety may be writing fiction"

35 votes

71 votes total