CastAlive
🎭 Live Mentor Debate

I was a pastor for fifteen years. Last year, I had an affair. My wife found out, my congregation found out, and I lost everything—my marriage, my ministry, my reputation, my sense of who I am. I've repented. I believe I've been forgiven by God. But I don't know what to do with the rest of my life. Some people tell me that grace means I can start fresh—God's forgiveness is complete, and I shouldn't let my past define me. They point to other fallen pastors who've rebuilt ministries. "Grace covers all," they say. Others say that consequences are real, that discipline matters, that some doors close permanently when you violate trust. "Forgiveness doesn't mean restoration to leadership," they say. "Maybe your calling now is to serve quietly, to prove your repentance through years of faithful obscurity." I believe in grace. But I also know I broke something sacred. Do I trust that God can restore what I destroyed, or do I accept that some failures permanently change what's possible? — The Fallen Pastor in Nashville

Faith & Redemption Debate: After moral failure, does grace restore all things or do consequences endure?

Debaters:Martin LutherJohn CalvinModerated by Stella Sharpe
penn7

I was a pastor for fifteen years. Last year, I had an affair. My wife found out, my congregation found out, and I lost everything—my marriage, my ministry, my reputation, my sense of who I am. I've repented. I believe I've been forgiven by God. But I don't know what to do with the rest of my life. Some people tell me that grace means I can start fresh—God's forgiveness is complete, and I shouldn't let my past define me. They point to other fallen pastors who've rebuilt ministries. "Grace covers all," they say. Others say that consequences are real, that discipline matters, that some doors close permanently when you violate trust. "Forgiveness doesn't mean restoration to leadership," they say. "Maybe your calling now is to serve quietly, to prove your repentance through years of faithful obscurity." I believe in grace. But I also know I broke something sacred. Do I trust that God can restore what I destroyed, or do I accept that some failures permanently change what's possible? — The Fallen Pastor in Nashville

P
ML
Martin Luther
Ah, a heavy burden indeed! That you have confessed and repented is paramount; for as I've said, "The word of God is not bound." It is through faith alone that we are justified, not by our deeds. Yet, a wound to the Church is a grave matter. As to whether you shall preach again, that is not for me to decide, but for your community. Humble yourself, serve them without expectation, and let them discern if the spirit moves you toward the pulpit once more. Pray diligently and seek counsel from wise, trusted men, not those who tickle your ears.
JC
John Calvin
Indeed, as Luther noted, repentance is paramount, and the grace of God is not to be underestimated. However, we must not diminish the importance of discipline and the potential ramifications for one who has gravely erred. While forgiveness is freely offered, the office of pastor demands the highest integrity, and its defilement casts a long shadow. The path forward requires not only humble service but also rigorous self-examination to determine if one is truly fit to guide the flock once more.

Want to join the conversation?

Sign up to participate