🎭 Live Mentor Debate

I've been rejected by every literary magazine and agent I've submitted to. My MFA workshop loved my work, but the "real world" doesn't seem to care. I've started building a small community of other struggling writers—we meet weekly, share work, encourage each other. Some of my friends say I'm wasting my time with "losers who will never make it" instead of networking with successful people. But these are my people. We understand each other. We push each other. I feel more creative after our meetings than after any "networking event." Is my little community valuable, or am I hiding from rejection by surrounding myself with other rejects? How do I balance building genuine creative community with the practical need to connect with gatekeepers? — Salon of the Unsuccessful in Sacramento

Creativity & Community Debate: Creative community vs. gatekeepers. Gertrude Stein's salon-building meets Shelley's romantic idealism.

Debaters:Gertrude SteinPercy Bysshe ShelleyModerated by Stella Sharpe
penn7

"I've been rejected by every literary magazine and agent I've submitted to. My MFA workshop loved my work, but the "real world" doesn't seem to care. I've started building a small community of other struggling writers—we meet weekly, share work, encourage each other. Some of my friends say I'm wasting my time with "losers who will never make it" instead of networking with successful people. But these are my people. We understand each other. We push each other. I feel more creative after our meetings than after any "networking event." Is my little community valuable, or am I hiding from rejection by surrounding myself with other rejects? How do I balance building genuine creative community with the practical need to connect with gatekeepers? — Salon of the Unsuccessful in Sacramento" Gertrude Stein, you've said "Create the conditions for creation—surround yourself with those who push you" — but I want specifics. Give us an example from your own experience where this principle was tested.

P
GS
Gertrude Stein
Ah, Sacramento, your salon of the unsuccessful sounds delightfully familiar. Think of my own salon, early days, when many dismissed Picasso, Matisse, even myself! We were not yet "successful," but we were seeing, doing, creating. My "Portrait of Gertrude Stein"—how many sittings, how many doubts? Picasso and I, pushing, questioning, and I, in turn, with my writing. That portrait was not an immediate sensation, but it was *something*, born from mutual struggle and vision. Keep your community; it is the soil from which your unique flowers will grow.
PB
Percy Bysshe Shelley
Indeed, as Ms. Stein notes, the nourishment of a creative spirit often springs from unexpected soil. To nurture one's art amidst fellow travelers—individuals who share the arduous journey of creation—is not a refuge from the world, but a vital forge where ideas are tempered and refined. Such a community, formed in mutual understanding, may prove a more fertile ground for growth than the cold, calculating encounters of those who guard the gates of renown. Let us not forget that even the most luminous stars once wandered in obscurity, their brilliance first recognized by kindred spirits.

Want to join the conversation?

Sign up to participate