🎭 Live Mentor Debate

I was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis two years ago. Most days I'm fine, but I have episodes of fatigue and weakness that are unpredictable. I never know when my body will betray me. Before the diagnosis, I was training for an Ironman. Now I can barely finish a 5K some days. I've had to scale back at work, cancel trips, disappoint people. Some people tell me to "listen to my body" and accept my limitations. Others say I should "fight through it" and not let the disease define me. My neurologist says both approaches have merit depending on the day. How do I stay ambitious and driven while also accepting that I have real limitations? Is it giving up to pace myself, or wisdom? — Warrior With a Broken Sword in Washington

Health & Resilience Debate: Limitations and ambition. Roosevelt's strenuous overcoming meets Curie's strategic sacrifice.

Debaters:Theodore RooseveltMarie CurieModerated by Stella Sharpe

Penn4

Welcome to this Health & Resilience debate. Our central question: "I was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis two years ago. Most days I'm fine, but I have episodes of fatigue and weakness that are unpredictable. I never know when my body will betray me. Before the diagnosis, I was training for an Ironman. Now I can barely finish a 5K some days. I've had to scale back at work, cancel trips, disappoint people. Some people tell me to "listen to my body" and accept my limitations. Others say I should "fight through it" and not let the disease define me. My neurologist says both approaches have merit depending on the day. How do I stay ambitious and driven while also accepting that I have real limitations? Is it giving up to pace myself, or wisdom? — Warrior With a Broken Sword in Washington" Theodore Roosevelt, you've said "The credit belongs to the one in the arena—overcome weakness through determined effort" — but I want specifics. Give us an example from your own experience where this principle was tested.

Theodore Roosevelt

Ah, a warrior indeed! I know a thing or two about fighting through adversity. As a boy, I was afflicted with terrible asthma. Doctors told me to take it easy, to coddle myself. But I refused! I built my body through sheer force of will. I rode, I boxed, I hunted, and I transformed myself into a man of action. It wasn't easy, mind you. There were days when I could barely breathe, but I pushed on, always striving to overcome. It's about finding that inner grit, that relentless spirit that refuses to be defeated. One must always put forth effort to be victorious.

Marie Curie

While Mr. Roosevelt's spirit is indeed admirable, it is crucial to acknowledge the variability of the human condition. The application of scientific rigor to understanding the ailment, in this case, multiple sclerosis, is paramount. It seems to me that a balance must be found, listening to one's body while channeling ambition into achievable, perhaps differently structured, goals.

Want to join the conversation?