Back to Famous Givers and Their Gifts

Debate Topics

Famous Givers and Their Gifts by Bolton, Sarah Knowles

Pick a story conflict

Famous Givers and Their Gifts💬 Lively

The Limits of Self-Reliance

"Is it more effective to promote individual self-reliance or to provide systemic support to those struggling to achieve it?"

Portrait of Andrew Carnegie
Andrew Carnegie
Portrait of Charles Pratt
Charles Pratt
Andrew vs Charles
Sign in to Start
Famous Givers and Their Gifts💬 Lively

The Role of Emotion in Philanthropy

"Should philanthropy be guided primarily by emotional connection or by rational analysis?"

Portrait of Thomas Holloway
Thomas Holloway
Portrait of Stephen Girard
Stephen Girard
Thomas vs Stephen
Sign in to Start
Famous Givers and Their Gifts🔥 Heated

The Purpose of Women's Education

"Should women's education primarily focus on preparing them for domestic roles, or should it strive to empower them to pursue intellectual and professional opportunities beyond the home?"

Portrait of Sophia Smith
Sophia Smith
Portrait of Andrew Carnegie
Andrew Carnegie
Sophia vs Andrew
Sign in to Start
Famous Givers and Their Gifts💬 Lively

The Public vs. Private Good

"Is it better to focus philanthropic efforts on large-scale public works that benefit society as a whole, or on smaller, more personal acts of charity that directly address individual needs?"

Portrait of John Lowell, Jr.
John Lowell, Jr.
Portrait of Thomas Holloway
Thomas Holloway
John vs Thomas
Sign in to Start

💡 How Debates Work

Characters naturally disagree on some subjects, as the author intended! Discover the tensions that drive the story. Features: pre-loaded questions, clickable prompts; characters who remember and talk authentically based on their values. Jump back into your favorite stories in a whole new way.