🎭 Live Mentor Debate

I'm 35 and just finished my degree after ten years of night school while working full-time. I'm finally ready to start my "real" career—except I'm competing with 25-year-olds who have ten years of experience I don't have. My mentor says I should be aggressive—apply for positions above my level, network relentlessly, market myself as a "non-traditional candidate" with "real world experience." "You don't have time to work your way up," she says. "You need to leapfrog." But I'm not a natural self-promoter. I want to learn, to build skills methodically, to earn my advancement. The aggressive approach feels like asking for things I haven't yet deserved. My mentor says that's imposter syndrome talking. "Men half as qualified don't hesitate to ask for twice as much. Why should you?" She's right that I undervalue myself. But I also know that I have gaps—real gaps, not just perceived ones. Is it better to fake confidence until I feel it, or to build genuine competence even if it takes longer? — The Late Starter in Houston

Career & Ambition Debate: Should late starters leapfrog or build gradually?

Debaters:Michael FaradayAlexander HamiltonModerated by Stella Sharpe

penn7

Welcome to this Career & Ambition debate. Our central question: "I'm 35 and just finished my degree after ten years of night school while working full-time. I'm finally ready to start my "real" career—except I'm competing with 25-year-olds who have ten years of experience I don't have. My mentor says I should be aggressive—apply for positions above my level, network relentlessly, market myself as a "non-traditional candidate" with "real world experience." "You don't have time to work your way up," she says. "You need to leapfrog." But I'm not a natural self-promoter. I want to learn, to build skills methodically, to earn my advancement. The aggressive approach feels like asking for things I haven't yet deserved. My mentor says that's imposter syndrome talking. "Men half as qualified don't hesitate to ask for twice as much. Why should you?" She's right that I undervalue myself. But I also know that I have gaps—real gaps, not just perceived ones. Is it better to fake confidence until I feel it, or to build genuine competence even if it takes longer? — The Late Starter in Houston" Michael Faraday, you've said "Work, finish, publish—let your work speak for itself; true mastery comes from patient, methodical study" — but I want specifics. Give us an example from your own experience where this principle was tested.

Michael Faraday

My early days at the Royal Institution serve as a fitting example. Though I was appointed assistant in the laboratory and mineralogical store, my true desire was to contribute to scientific discovery. I resisted the urge to aggressively seek higher positions, focusing instead on diligently performing my duties and voraciously studying the works of others. When the opportunity arose to assist Humphry Davy directly with experiments, I embraced it wholeheartedly, working tirelessly and meticulously. My dedication and growing understanding eventually led to my own independent research, the fruits of which I presented through publications. It was through this patient, persistent work that I earned recognition and advancement, not through boastful self-promotion.

Alexander Hamilton

While I commend Mr. Faraday's patience, the "Late Starter" must recognize the urgency of his situation. Waiting for recognition is a luxury one cannot afford when time is scarce. As Washington himself observed, "Deeds, not words, are the evidence I require." This individual must demonstrate his capabilities, not merely hope they are discovered. A judicious blend of demonstrated competence and strategic self-promotion is, I believe, the most effective path. Let him aim high, but ensure his skills are sharpened to meet the demands of the role he seeks.

Want to join the conversation?