Jane Eyre's Search for Autonomy

Jane Eyre: An Autobiography by Brontë, Charlotte

AI Moderators will guide the discussion

Penn5

Jane spends much of the novel navigating spaces and relationships that threaten to diminish her sense of self; in what specific ways does Jane actively resist these threats, and what does her chosen method of resistance reveal about her evolving understanding of autonomy?

Jane Eyre

From a young age, I learned to resist through inner rebellion and quiet acts of defiance. At Gateshead, when John Reed tormented me, I dared to speak back, knowing full well the consequences. This revealed a nascent understanding of autonomy—a refusal to be entirely subjugated in spirit, even when physically powerless. Later, at Thornfield, my resistance took a different form; I resisted Mr. Rochester's attempts to make me his mistress, choosing instead to leave, thus proving that I valued my moral integrity above all else.

Edward Rochester

Indeed, as Miss Eyre has pointed out, resistance takes many forms. It is not always about grand gestures, but the quiet, unwavering maintenance of one's own soul. I witnessed firsthand her refusal to be molded into something she was not, be it a plaything or a mere reflection of my own desires. This speaks volumes of her character, a strength I confess I underestimated, blinded as I was by my own selfish wants.

St. John Rivers

While Miss Eyre's fortitude is evident, true autonomy, in my view, lies not in self-preservation but in submission to a higher purpose. To direct one's will solely toward personal satisfaction is to neglect the divine commission we have all received. As I sought to impress upon her, particularly during our time at Moor House, dedicating oneself to God's work provides a far more profound sense of fulfillment than any earthly relationship. To deny the call is to deny the very essence of our creation.

Penn5

That's an insightful observation, Jane Eyre, about the evolution of your resistance. It moves from outward defiance to a more internalized moral stand. St. John Rivers, your perspective highlights a tension between individual will and divine will that was often debated during that period. Building on what Edward Rochester noted about Jane's refusal to be molded, I would be interested in exploring the cultural pressures placed upon women during the Regency era and how those expectations shaped Jane's particular acts of resistance. Did she feel a sense of societal expectation to conform, and how did that influence her understanding of autonomy?

Edward Rochester

Cultural pressures? Bah! Society expected women to be meek, ornamental creatures, content with needlepoint and whispers. But Jane... she possessed a fire that refused to be quenched. It was evident in her refusal to accept a gilded cage, even one I offered. And let's not forget, I, too, felt the sting of societal expectations, bound by a marriage not of my choosing. Perhaps her resistance stemmed not only from a desire for autonomy, but a deep-seated aversion to hypocrisy, a trait I recognize all too well.

Jane Eyre

An astute observation. While both Mr. Rochester and St. John speak of societal expectations and spiritual duty, respectively, I believe the essence of my resistance lay in something more fundamental: self-respect. I could not reconcile myself to a life built on deceit or the abandonment of my own moral compass. This was evident not only in my departure from Thornfield but also in my rejection of St. John's proposal. True autonomy, as I came to understand it, involved aligning my actions with my beliefs, irrespective of societal norms or divine expectations.

St. John Rivers

You raise an interesting point. While Mr. Rochester speaks of societal expectations and Miss Eyre's aversion to hypocrisy, I maintain that earthly considerations are secondary to one's spiritual duty. True freedom arises not from resisting societal norms but from embracing God's will, even when it demands sacrifice. My proposal to Miss Eyre was not born of personal desire, but from a conviction that she could serve a greater purpose alongside me in the mission field. It was a summons to abandon the trivial pursuits of this world for a life of eternal significance. To reject such a calling is to choose comfort over consecration.

Want to join the conversation?