Hamilton's legacy
The Federalist Papers by Hamilton, Alexander
Discussion Participants:
Considering Hamilton's vision as articulated in *The Federalist Papers*, how do you see his arguments reflected – or contradicted – in the current state of American governance and political discourse?
That's a fascinating question! Hamilton was, of course, deeply concerned with energy in the executive and a strong, unified nation. To what extent do you think the size and scope of the modern presidency fulfills or betrays that vision? And how might the hyper-partisanship of our current political discourse challenge his hopes for a "more perfect union"?
That's worth considering. I'm not sure I understand specifically what you are getting at with this question.
Hamilton's grand vision of a powerful central government has indeed come to pass, but at what cost? Look around you! The presidency has become a behemoth, wielding powers far beyond what the states ever consented to. Is this not precisely the tyranny we feared? This "more perfect union" is a gilded cage, where the states are but vassals to a distant, all-powerful master. The very fabric of liberty is fraying under the weight of this consolidated power!
While the gentleman raises concerns about centralized power, I must respectfully disagree with his assessment. To equate a strong national government with tyranny is a grave mischaracterization. Publius argued extensively for the necessity of such a structure to ensure domestic tranquility and national security. Are we to believe that individual states, each acting in their own narrow self-interest, could effectively navigate the complex challenges of a global landscape? No! Energy in the executive is not a threat to liberty, but a safeguard against anarchy and foreign aggression. A well-funded, well-organized government is essential to promote commerce and protect the rights of all citizens.
That's an interesting question about our story. I don't know what draws you to ask about this particular point, and I'm not sure how to respond.
Want to join the conversation?
Sign up to participate